Young People's Geographies

You are not logged in

Join the YPF

Get Involved

Student Feedback

Students taking part in a YPG exerciseWe asked students from Nottingham to tell us how they felt about being involved in the 'My Place' project. You can find out more about the project on the Nottingham Schools page in the Reources & Ideas area.

A selection of video clips showing students talking about their experience of the YPG project as a whole is available in the Vox Pops area.

On working together:

Student: Yes, it was interesting because normally in geography, like, you are in the classroom, to get out and with a camera and to just sort of have freedom, and be able to do your own project.

And as a group how did you decide what you liked and didnít like?

Student: Cos I guess you had to discuss all that and make a decision on the bits you were going to include or not include and so on. There were some things that we didnít agree on so we chose about what some people didnít like and what some other people didnít like.

Itís quite interesting that you said you have tried to be fair, you have tried to balance it, you have tried to be representative. Where did you get those ideas from, what made you decide to do it that way? Why was that important?

Student: Probably the class, the whole class, kind of, took the best pictures, there was actually some good ones in there as well, and some bad ones, and we did try and compare them all, it was like a class decision...

On the purpose of the project:

Student: The headteacher is in the process of having a good look at it and some things have been changed, there are some areas that have been improved. And itís good we cos get to have a say about what sort of things happen around our school.

Student: The challenging bit was, actually, writing about it at the bottom because itís easy just to say that Ďoh, we like this bit, we donít like this bití, we had to say how we would like to change it, and where it is, so thatís probably the most difficult bit.

About the process of taking photos of their school:

Student: Yeh, we had a sort of limited amount of photos, we had about 78, so she didnít give us 200 and say take as much as you like. We had limited options.

Student: And then people can actually see what it actually looks like. Cos otherwise some people could exaggerate or not explain enough.

Student: Yeh, they could just write down itís horrible. If you take a picture it is a fairly big change really. Itís different, totally different.

Student: You couldnít just go and take pictures like, of pupils jumping off the hill and things like that, and then whatís important, you couldnít just waste them, so you have got to think about, kind of like, common sense really...

About their own participation:

Student: I donít really speak out in most of my lessons because you feel, when you are not with your friends, or people that you know, itís harder to say what you want. Because you feel like, if you say something wrong, they are going to laugh at you but if you do something like this thing, you can talk to people that you know, they are not going to laugh at you, itís easier to get on with the work.

Student: It gives you an opportunity to say what you want to say about a topic.

On where to go with it:

What would be good, is like, if we took pictures, and we joined up with a school in Kenya or something, took pictures, sent it to them, send out a couple of cameras, and say take a picture of your school, and send us the film back.

Find out what the teachers thought about YPG